Missouri Valley is considering rezoning 54 properties along the Erie Street corridor, but an August 4 public hearing raised questions about confusing notices, the planning cited to support the proposal and why a corridor wide zoning change is needed when property owners already have a process to request rezoning individually.
A proposal to change the zoning of dozens of properties along Missouri Valley’s Erie Street corridor led to nearly 37 minutes of questions during an August 4 public hearing.
The city is considering changing certain properties from R2 Residential to C1 Central Business District. City officials repeatedly assured residents that existing homes would not have to be converted into businesses and homeowners would not be forced to move or sell.
But as the hearing progressed, a different issue took center stage.
The letter sent to affected property owners said the proposal was based on a review of the Erie Street corridor by the Planning and Zoning Commission and other long range planning efforts being considered by the city. When residents and Missouri Valley Voices asked what that review consisted of, what findings were made, what recommendations resulted from it and what specific benefit the broader rezoning would provide, Building Official John Harrison was unable to provide those details during the hearing. Harrison is listed by the city as Missouri Valley’s Building Official.
The Proposal
According to the notice read during the hearing, the Planning and Zoning Commission agreed at its June 8 meeting to begin the public hearing process to consider rezoning certain properties along Erie Street to C1 Central Business District.
For affected residential properties, the proposed change would move them from R2 Residential to C1.
Harrison later clarified that 54 properties were included in the proposed rezoning. Because some owners have more than one affected parcel, 51 letters were sent to owners of the properties being considered for rezoning. Another 109 notices were sent to neighboring property owners.
Before the city’s notice could even be read aloud at the hearing, Harrison was asked whether he had brought the proposal or letter with him.
“I didn’t bring the letter,” Harrison responded before another copy was provided for the discussion.
The language in that letter would become important later in the hearing.
The notice said the purpose of the proposed rezoning was to determine whether a more consistent zoning pattern along Erie Street would better support the area’s long term development. It went further, stating that the proposal was based on the Planning and Zoning Commission’s review of the corridor and other long range planning efforts under consideration by the city.
Residents say the notice created confusion
Before questions turned to the planning behind the proposal, residents raised concerns about the information the city had mailed.
Terrie White told the council she was not one of the property owners being rezoned but had received a notice because she lived near the proposed area.
White said she received the letter on the Friday before the Tuesday hearing. She said the map included with the notice was small, cross streets were cut off, there was no legend and she could not determine what the different colors represented.
“It was just hard to read. It was small. There’s no legend,” White told the council.
The discussion eventually clarified that blue lines White was attempting to interpret were parcel boundaries from the Beacon map rather than another zoning classification. Yellow highlighting showed the proposed Central Business area.
White also pointed out that the letter directed residents with questions to “please contact,” but no contact information followed.
She told the council that with only a few days before the hearing, she had attempted to research the proposal herself but was left confused about where to get additional information.
Council member, Russ Meadows, told Harrison that White was not the only person who had raised those concerns.
“I had multiple people come to me about this letter,” the council member said, adding that it was “hard to read” and “a little confusing.”
The council member said residents had brought her the same paperwork and asked many of the same questions.
That was notable because the letter itself stated that it was intended to provide affected residents with additional information explaining the proposal.
What happens to existing homes?
One question the city did answer repeatedly was what would happen to the people already living in the proposed commercial district.
The letter said homeowners would not be required to move, sell their homes, convert their property into a business or make improvements because of the zoning change. Existing residential use could continue.
The primary effect, according to the city, would be on future land use and redevelopment.
Officials also said a homeowner could later sell the property to another person who could continue using it as a residence.
“They’re not going to be forced into a commercial situation,” one city official said during the discussion.
But if existing homes could remain residential, residents wanted to know why the city believed changing their zoning now was necessary.
“There’s not a huge need”
Resident Cheryl Hellstrom questioned whether Missouri Valley currently has a need for more commercial property, pointing to commercial properties already sitting vacant along the corridor.
Harrison acknowledged that there was not an immediate demand driving the proposal.
“There’s not a huge need to take over the area,” Harrison said. “There’s a huge need to look to the future of Missouri Valley and what can the city become.”
He continued by discussing what Missouri Valley might look like 10, 15 or 20 years from now.
A council member then stepped into the discussion, saying, “just to help you out here a little bit,” and suggested that future changes involving Highway 30 were part of that bigger planning picture. Harrison agreed.
The explanation established that the proposal was not being driven by an immediate need to redevelop the 54 properties.
Instead, officials described it as future land use planning.
That made the planning cited in the city’s letter increasingly important.
Future commercial uses raise additional questions
Residents also questioned what C1 zoning could eventually mean for neighborhoods that remain primarily residential.
The hearing included discussion about commercial setbacks, how much of a commercial lot can be developed and what types of businesses could potentially locate next to existing homes.
Pawn shops and liquor stores were raised as examples during the discussion. Officials agreed those could be permitted commercial uses, while also clarifying that industrial uses would not be allowed in the C1 district.
Harrison also pointed to provisions requiring a barrier where commercial property abuts residential property.
Those concerns reinforced what city officials had already said: the proposed zoning change may not alter how a property is being used today, but it could substantially change the range of future uses available for that property.
That is when Missouri Valley Voices returned to the language the city had used to justify the proposal.
Where is the corridor review?
Missouri Valley Voices asked Harrison to explain what the Planning and Zoning Commission’s review of the corridor actually involved.
MVV asked what the scope of the review was, what findings came from it, what recommendations were made and what the city’s long term development plan was.
Harrison responded:
“I don’t have all that documentation in front of me.”
Harrison then referenced the city’s broader comprehensive planning process and discussed the committee involved in creating the Comprehensive Plan.
The city does have a current Comprehensive Plan, which is listed with the city’s adopted planning and zoning resources.
But that raised another question.
If the Erie Street proposal resulted from the long range planning described in the letter, would someone opening the Comprehensive Plan find the details of the Erie Street corridor proposal?
Harrison said no.
When MVV asked whether the Comprehensive Plan would contain all of the details about the corridor, Harrison explained that the Erie proposal had come out of discussions but was not specifically contained within the broader plan.
A council member then explained why a Comprehensive Plan itself is important, including its value when prospective businesses look at a community and when cities seek grants.
The issue, however, was not whether Missouri Valley should have a Comprehensive Plan.
The question was what specific review, findings or recommendations supported changing the zoning of these particular 54 properties.
The materials online did not answer that question
MVV again pointed to the language in the city’s notice.
Residents had been told the proposed zoning change was based on a corridor review and long range planning. Yet the specific review findings or recommendations had not been identified during the hearing.
Officials said the information was available on the city’s website.
When asked what could be found there, the materials identified were the Erie Street map, a list of affected properties and a fact sheet.
As of August 11, the city’s own Minutes and Agendas page continues to list Erie Street Zoning Changes under “Pending Items.” The two Erie Street resources displayed there are “Selected Properties” and a “Common Questions” fact sheet.
No separate Erie Street corridor study, findings report or detailed redevelopment plan is identified on that page.
That does not mean planning discussions did not occur.
It does mean that during the August 4 hearing, the city did not produce the specific corridor review, findings or recommendations that residents were asking for after reading the city’s notice.
One resident explained why he supports rezoning
Not everyone at the hearing opposed the proposal.
Chris Cleaver told the council he wanted to be on record supporting rezoning.
Cleaver discussed a property he was interested in purchasing that had previously been used as a six unit property but, under its current zoning, could now be used only as a duplex.
“It doesn’t make sense to me not to make a property that big into more than a duplex,” Cleaver said. “So, I’m very much in favor of rezonings.”
Cleaver’s comments provided one of the clearest examples during the hearing of how different zoning could benefit an owner or prospective buyer who has a specific use in mind.
They also highlighted another question.
Missouri Valley already has a process for property owners who want their own property rezoned.
Individual property owners can already request rezoning
Missouri Valley’s current zoning ordinance allows amendments to the official zoning map to be initiated not only by the city, Planning and Zoning Commission or other authorized boards, but also by an individual property owner.
An owner seeking a zoning map change can submit an application through the Building Official. The current ordinance provides for an application fee, review by the Planning and Zoning Commission, a public hearing and a recommendation to the City Council. The Council ultimately decides whether the zoning amendment is approved. The city currently lists this ordinance as its adopted 2026 Zoning Ordinance.
The process is not merely theoretical.
In January 2025, the City Council approved and adopted Ordinance 612 changing the zoning of a single parcel at 323 West Erie Street from Duplex Residential to Central Business.
The city’s Building Division also maintains a list of numerous previous ordinances changing individual zoning classifications throughout Missouri Valley.
That does not mean the city cannot initiate a broader zoning change. The current ordinance also allows city initiated amendments.
But it raises a policy question that was not clearly answered during the August 4 hearing:
Why is it necessary to preemptively change the zoning of 54 properties when owners who actually want commercial zoning already have a process to request it?
That question becomes more significant when considered alongside Harrison’s statement that there is currently “not a huge need” to redevelop the area.
The hearing ends where it began
Near the end of the hearing, resident Don Blackford returned to the same issue.
Blackford asked what the city’s referenced long term plan actually was for Erie Street.
Harrison responded:
“I don’t have the document in front of me, sir.”
Blackford continued, asking whether Harrison knew what the plan was without looking at the document.
“I don’t know all the details off the top of my head,” Harrison responded.
Blackford then asked about the purpose of the rezoning.
The response was that the proposal was not intended to take anyone’s property or arbitrarily raise taxes, but was instead about redesigning the future layout of Missouri Valley.
“What is the layout?” Blackford asked.
“Change the business zoning,” came the response.
The hearing closed seconds later.
The city has explained what could change. The question is why?
By the end of the August 4 hearing, residents had received answers to some important questions.
Existing homeowners would not be forced to convert their properties to businesses. Residential uses could continue. The proposal is intended to affect future land use rather than force immediate redevelopment.
What remained unanswered was the central justification for making the change across 54 properties.
The city’s notice says the proposal grew out of a Planning and Zoning Commission review of the corridor and long range planning efforts.
Yet when asked for the scope of that review, its findings and its recommendations, the Building Official, John Harrison, did not have them available.
When the Comprehensive Plan was cited, building official, John Harrison, acknowledged that the specific Erie Street proposal was not contained within it.
When online materials were identified by Harrison, they consisted of a map, affected property information and a fact sheet rather than a separate corridor study or development plan.
And when another resident asked for the plan again near the end of the hearing, Harrison again said he did not have the document in front of him and could not provide its details.
Meanwhile, Missouri Valley already has a process allowing an individual property owner to seek a zoning change when that owner has a specific need for one.
The city has made clear what it is proposing to change.
After the August 4 public hearing, the larger question remains:
What specific problem does rezoning these 54 properties solve, and what documented benefit does the broader change provide that the city’s existing individual rezoning process does not?
As of August 11, the city continues to list the Erie Street zoning changes as a pending item.

Leave a Reply